God and Amputees

Last week I posted a video link that asked 10 questions that every intelligent Christian must answer. One of my readers (heissailing) commented on his blog about question #1 Why won’t God heal amputees? One of the questions he raises which I think is even more intriguing than why God won’t heal them. Why won’t Christians pray for amputees to be healed?

Sure, they will pray for someone with cancer and give the glory to God when the treatments made possible through science put the cancer into remission. Sure, they will pray for God to guide a surgeon’s hands and pray for a quick recovery. Sure, they will pray for someone to get a job or a promotion - something that the person must go out and work for. Sure, they will pray for a blessing over the food - something that there is no proof of happening or not. It seems as though Christians only pray for things that take no faith. Heissailing proposes that we never ask for the miraculous because, deep down, even though we are afraid to admit it, we know the miraculous, supernatural healing of God never occurs.

“But we rarely ever pray for an actual miraculous intervention of the supernatural.”

I once met a man who had been prayed for to restore his hearing. He had had to take an early retirement because his job depended on his ability to hear. But God did not heal him. But did the congregation blame God? No, they blamed the man for not having enough faith. This man never let anybody pray for him again.

Heissailing relates a story of somebody in his church saying he prayed for an amputee and his arm grew back right then and there. But nobody believed him.

“Why did nobody believe him? Because deep down, we know but are afraid to admit, miracles do not happen. If you start telling people that you saw an amputee grow his arm back, people, even believing Christians, will think you are a bit nuts. So instead of believing in the truly miraculous, we are willing to accept God granting people jobs and slowly recovering from illnesses that happen at the same rate as the heathen who never acknowledge God for anything.”

Read the rest of heissailing’s post here. He has some interesting thoughts in “My Miraculous Hangup.”


Technorati : , , ,
Del.icio.us : , , ,
Ice Rocket : , , ,


2 Responses to “God and Amputees”

  1. Mary Says:

    Hi again! I haven’t looked in for a while and I remember why now. Too much negativity and antichristian sentiment. I thought the definition on atheism was the “disbelief in the existences of deities”. But most of the posts here appear to be “Christian bashing” unless I missed comments on Jewish or Muslim beliefs. It seems that some of your post imply there is a lack of intelligence in people who believe in a God. I am friends (or related to) with physicians, physicists, engineers and university professors who are devoted Christians, have read the Bible multiple times and spent most of their lives studying it and believe. Trying to figure out why people worship and believe in God is like trying to figure out why people fall in love. There is no rhyme or reason why we love certain people, how we can explain why we feel love for someone? I understand that you don’t love or believe in God anymore, but why belittle the love or belief that others feel? I think the answer to the question of why your friends and relatives don’t witness to you is that you have already now what is available to you. I guess witnessing is for those who do not know about God and you already do. Or that is my thoughts on it. Of course I pray for you daily as does Carl because we love you. How could I live with myself believing what I do and not? I pray for enemies so of course my own sister has to top the list. I don’t know why some people have their physical ailments healed and others don’t. I don’t know why God hasn’t healed my RA and why I live in constant pain. Paul asked God to heal him and God didn’t. I guess I am in good company :) I love you!

  2. Theresa Says:

    I was going to comment here, but it was getting too long. Instead I will make it a post.

Leave a Comment